By year of induction
 Chuck Dima |
 John Panarace |
 Mike Brouse |
 Randy Price |
Richie Diaz* |
Burt Sachs |
 Al Messia |
 Stan Witt |
 Reggie Brown |
Sammye Coker |
Derek Danton |
 Saul Fishman |
 Ronnie Page |
Bart Rosenberg |
Ira Scott* |
Mike Carey* |
Earle Dersham* |
Jerry Fitzpatrick* |
Chris Lanni |
Bruce Levine |
Marcelo Soriano |
Jimmy Stathes |
 Michael Yang |
Robert Ricca |
Josh Rosenbluth |
Dee Schaefer |
* Deceased